Great guy, not-so-great dad

by: Cynthia MacGregor

No matter how negative your feelings about marriage were when you first got divorced, there comes a time in almost every divorcée’s life when she starts dating again and even thinking that a second marriage may lie in her future.

But things are different now than they were when you were a young and single, dating men and responsible for only yourself. Now it’s a package deal. Now it’s you and the kids. And now, any fellow you’d consider marrying needs to be evaluated not just for his suitability as a husband but for his potential as a dad.

What’s more, he may well have kids of his own. And they have to figure into the equation, too. Even if they don’t live with him, they surely spend some time with him. This may be every weekend, every other weekend, Wednesday nights or, if he and his ex live in cities that are distant from each other, the kids may spend all summer with him, and probably some time on other school breaks, too.

But even leaving aside the question of whether you get along with his kids or whether your kids get along with his, he himself may be problematic. If you were able to prevent the new man in your life from meeting your kids till after you were sure he had real husband potential — a suggestion I’ve given the reasons for in previous articles in this space— you probably didn’t have a chance to see how he interacts with kids. When you finally introduced him to your kids, though, you may have been disappointed or even dismayed at the way he treated them.

Of course, I’m assuming that if he got out of line you would toss him out faster than week-old garbage. But what if he doesn’t abuse the kids or anything drastic like that, but your parenting style and his simply don’t mesh? What if you’re a lenient, laissez-faire type and he’s a strict, you’d-better-toe-the-line disciplinarian? Or, for that matter, vice-versa? What if your rules and expectations vary radically, and he won’t change his views?

It may be a no-hope situation. But before you sadly shut the door behind him forever, consider what accommodations he might make for you and maybe you’ll need to bend a little, too. If he’s a rational, thinking human being and you point out that the kids have been raised a certain way, with certain rules and certain guidelines, he may realize that even if he doesn’t agree with all your precepts, methodology, or thinking, it’s unfair to change the rules on the kids at this stage of the game. (This is, of course, more true if they are, say, 11 and 14 than if they are three and five.)

He may have to go against his own beliefs and raise the kids your way for the most part — with certain exceptions. And you may have to alter some of your thinking too, if not your actual thinking, then the rules and standards under which you operate with your kids. If your new love is adamant that your 13-year-old son is old enough to shoulder certain responsibilities you think he’s too young for, or that your 15-year-old daughter needs an 11:00 curfew at all times, even though you’ve let her stay out till midnight under certain special circumstances, you may have to acquiesce to his beliefs.

But if your thinking is radically different from his, he isn’t willing to change his beliefs, and neither are you, this may spell the end of an otherwise great relationship. And if his style of parenting strikes you as flat-out wrong — not just different from yours but wrong —run, don’t walk, to the nearest exit.

If he allows the kids to engage in behaviors that could endanger them, or if he is so ultra-lenient that the kids have no discipline at all or so ultra-strict that the kids feel like he’s a jailer, and you agree with them, or if their disciplinary infractions result in his meting out seriously humiliating punishments? This man is not for you, no matter how wonderful, kind, generous, caring, thoughtful, and considerate he is to you.

Face it. You’re not a solo act anymore. You’re part of a package deal. And if he’s not a good dad, or he’s not the kind of dad you want for your kids, he’s just not your Mr. Right. 

Cynthia MacGregor is a multi-published author with over 100 books to her credit, of which roughly half were published conventionally and the remainder as e-books. They include After Your Divorce, Divorce Helpbook for Kids, Divorce Helpbook for Teens, Solo Parenting, "Step" This Way, and others. Forthcoming books include The One-Parent Family, Why Are Mommy and Daddy Getting Divorced, and Daddy Doesn't Live Here Anymore. She does write on other subjects besides divorce! To see the full range of her books, please visit www.cynthiamacgregor.com. For nearly two years she hosted and produced the TV show Solo Parenting, which was broadcast in South Florida over WHDT. Her column "Solo Parenting" appeared on www.TheSoloParent.com (now out of business) and DangerousLee.biz.

Besides writing books, Cynthia is available for freelance writing assignments of most types as well as freelance editing. She has edited books, magazines, web copy, business materials, and more. She has also ghostwritten books for others. Cynthia has had nearly a dozen one-act plays staged, most notably by the Palm Springs Players, a community theatre group in Palm Springs FL. One of her shows, King Theo, written for a family audience, was produced in New York in the ’90s. Her song "America Again" (she wrote the lyrics) can be heard at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TyJF4rvTo6w&feature=youtu.be. You can contact Cynthia with inquiries about her books, about writing or editing assignments, or on other matters at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Cynthia is a contributing expert at HopeAfterDivorce.org, FamilyShare.com, CupidsPulse.com, and LAFamily.com.




Legal Disclaimer- Important Information Regarding the Use of This Website

This website is intended to provide general information only. No legal advice is provided or intended to be provided on this website or through communication with any representative on behalf of Divorce Support Center. Each case rests on its own unique set of facts and the general information provided in this website cannot be relied upon to make legal decisions. Other laws not addressed in this website may govern your case. While the information provided in this website is believed to be accurate, the law is constantly changing and no information contained in this website may be relied upon. Visitors to the website use the information contained herein at their own risk. Visitors to the website are urged to seek out competent legal counsel who can apply the current law to the unique facts of their case. No warranties or guarantees, either express or implied, are given.
Under no circumstances does this website, directly or indirectly, including but not limited to, communication by any means to or from Divorce Support Center , establish or intend to establish an attorney-client relationship between you and Divorce Support Center , as Divorce Support Center is not a law firm, and therefore does not and cannot render legal advice to the general public and is not engaged in the practice of law. Should you desire legal representation, Divorce Support Center may be able to refer a licensed attorney in your area, upon request.
You are here: Home Park Blog Great guy, not-so-great dad